Sally Robertson
Eli Cameron
Government & Socioeconomics
17 Dec. 2010
The Voice of San Diego
A fact well acknowledged in the United States of America is that our government was founded with three branches: Executive, Legislative, and Judicial. These three branches were designed to work in a system of checks and balances, each branch keeping the others in line and free from corruption as much as possible. Some people consider there to a fourth branch of government, one that is not necessarily recognized in the United States Constitution, nor one that people are elected for, but nonetheless it plays its role ensuring that our government does right by its citizens. The United States’ media serves, ideally, as a watchdog for democracy, evaluating the efforts of America’s politicians, and educating everyday citizens in order to keep everyone aware. America’s history is littered with events where the media has stepped in when the government did wrong; reporters Bob Woodard and Carl Burnstien and their investigation of the Watergate Scandal are jus one such instance. While the effectiveness of some media sources in this arena is questionable at times, due to bias or their occasional exclusion of the whole truth, others work tirelessly to fulfill this role. The efforts and goals of the Voice of San Diego, a local online news organization, are completely in tune with this imperative responsibility by keeping not only locally elected officials in check, but also local news organizations, in addition to providing important news to San Diego’s inhabitants.
The goals of the Voice of San Diego are simple and are the same as just about any news organization: they wish to inform the public of important news in such areas as politics, educational, environment, and the economy. But what separates them from many news organizations, however, is how they choose the news they want to share with their readers. Rather than spending time writing dozens of articles, some of which may have questionable newsworthiness, they find the most important stories and spend more time and effort into getting investigating a topic into as great a depth as they can, and then reporting this information to the public. This is a sincere issue with news today. When reading many of today’s local news sites, I find myself looking at headlines for articles and wondering why they were written. I do not and cannot understand the significance of the articles that describe the best restaurants in downtown San Diego and other pieces of a similar nature, when there is other news, whether it is on a local, national, or international level, it should take precedence.
Also important is their determination for their articles to remain objective and free from bias. Ideally, all news organizations should provide unbiased information, or representing both sides of an issue. Doing so allows the reader to understand the situation fully and inform his or her own opinions, rather than understanding only half of an issue, which can lead to confusion and misunderstanding. For this reason, neutral news reporting is one of the first lessons taught in journalism; journalists are expected to keep their opinions about issues to themselves, especially when it comes to writing news articles.
I learned in my very first visit to the Voice of San Diego that this particular organization strives to remain impartial. Upon entering the Voice of San Diego’s office, and after being introduced to its staff members, I was asked to introduce my self; I explained that I was coming to volunteer with the Voice of San Diego as part of my Government and Socioeconomics class, which required that I work with a politically affiliated organization. One of the reporters turned to my mentor, her boss, Andrew Donohue and asked, if the Voice of San Diego was connected to a political organization or ideology. Andrew Donohue later explained to me that while the Voice of San Diego did report on government and politics, they tried to present all of their news in an unbiased manner in order to uphold this ideal journalistic trait.
Working at the Voice of San Diego has also allowed me to compare it to other news organizations. Before working at the Voice of San Diego, I interned for three weeks at the San Diego News Network, another local online news publication, which sadly has been suffering of late due to the economic recession. One interesting difference between the two organizations was the quality of the articles put out; the San Diego News Network is an organization that, as previously mentioned, has the tendency to publish articles of questionable newsworthiness. But another great difference I notice between the Voice of San Diego and the San Diego News Network is the amount of work that is completed by contributors.
At the San Diego News Network, local members of the community who have written articles to be published, whom are otherwise known as contributors, publish a large percentage of their articles. The remaining percentage belongs to its own staff. At the Voice of San Diego, on the other hand, nearly all of their articles are written by staff members, making more use of the staff members employed, in addition to having more of their articles written by authentic journalists who have been educated in this field.
This also introduces the idea of competition in local journalism, and why it is so important. By having an array of viable local news sources, such as the Union Tribune, the Voice of San Diego, and the San Diego News Network, people multiple potential sources of news. Just as competition between multiple companies in a particular industry prevents the creation of monopolies, having multiple local news organizations allows there to be diversity in the news; this prevents the possibility of only one idea or opinion being presented to citizens when, by having more than one local news organization there is competition to provide the best news possible.
Beyond all of their other efforts, however, to be a productive and informative news organization, the Voice of San Diego’s fact check blog is a direct example of how they act as a watchdog for democracy, a vital piece of the checks and balances system. The purpose of the fact check blog is to evaluate statements from a variety of sources and give them a rating based on how accurate information is. These sources can include nearly anything; other news organizations and political candidates running for office are just two examples. The purpose of the fact check blog is not to collect all of the false statements produced in order to give certain people or groups a bad name. Statements have the ability of receiving a rating of “true” as well, and after all, allowing citizens to understand what information is truly accurate is just as important as the information that is blatantly false, but allowing citizens to recognize inaccurate information is vital.
My primary job while working at the Voice of San Diego was working on the fact check blog. The process of finding a fact check starts with finding a statement to fact check. I would spend my time at volunteership reading statements given by political candidates, campaign websites, local news organizations, and more in order to find statements that seemed bold, something that made me pause and wonder if it was truly accurate. These statements and their sources were recorded. Then, the staff member in charge of the Fact check blog, Keegan, would weed through all of the statements I found and select a few which could be easily checked. Once this was done, I could begin trying to find information either corroborating or disproving statements. At times, this was as simple as finding statistics on the internet, for example, if I was fact checking a statement that Poway has the lowest crime rate in San Diego county. Sometimes, however, more work became involved.
My biggest fact check that I worked on was a fact check on a Union Tribune article published last August that claimed that San Diego had the largest budget for spending money per fire fighter we had in employment. The San Diego budget was compared to a number of other cities, one of which was Los Angeles. The Voice of San Diego was curious if the comparison of budgets were a truly apples to apples comparison, in other words, the budgets of both cities included the same types of costs. If they didn’t, the Union Tribune would have published faulty information.
This work that I completed, and which future volunteers could easily participate in, was extremely worthwhile. My job was to help hold people accountable for their statements and ensure that people from San Diego are able to understand the truth. People who do not present accurate information are misleading society, and the Voice of San Diego’s efforts to refute this information holds true to the highest standards of journalism.
The Voice of San Diego has made amazing contributions to San Diego county and it’s inhabitants’ ability to read accurate news. They have worked to present in-depth pieces about important issues, rather than on topics that are unimportant. They also prevent themselves from presenting any form of bias that could mislead citizens just as much as the statements they work to fact check. These efforts have allowed them to achieve and surpass their ultimate goal of educating San Diego on important news.